Nickel collecting is more than just a hobby—it’s a treasure hunt. Some nickels are so rare and historically important that they can sell for millions.
From minting errors to ultra-low production runs, these coins have become legendary among collectors. Here are five of the rarest nickels in U.S. history that together could be worth an astonishing $250 million.
Nickels With a Legendary Past
Some rare nickels are famous not just for their scarcity, but for their stories.
One of the most legendary is the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel. Only five were ever made, and they weren’t supposed to exist because the U.S. Mint had already switched to the Buffalo Nickel design. In 2010, one sold for $3.7 million, and experts believe a flawless example could bring $20 million today.
Another treasure is the 1870 Shield Nickel in proof condition. Only a few are known to exist, and because of their age and rarity, one could sell for $5 million or more.
Mint Mistakes That Turned Into Millions
Minting errors can turn an ordinary coin into a collector’s dream.
The 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel is a famous example. A mint worker accidentally polished away one of the buffalo’s legs, leaving it with only three. In top condition, this quirky coin has sold for $2.5 million.
Then there’s the 1942/1 Jefferson Nickel, created when a 1942 die was mistakenly struck over a 1941 design. Because so few exist, a pristine specimen could command $10 million at auction.
Why These Nickels Are So Rare
Some coins are scarce simply because very few were made or because most were lost over time.
The 1885 Liberty Head Nickel had a low mintage and many didn’t survive. One perfect coin sold for $3 million in 2007, but today it could bring $8 million or more.
Another gem is the 1867 Rays Shield Nickel, which features a distinctive ray design around the shield. Only a small number remain in great condition, with the best examples fetching up to $5 million.
Estimated Values of the Rarest Nickels
Here’s a quick look at the coins and their potential worth:
| Nickel Name | Year | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| 1913 Liberty Head | 1913 | Up to $20 million |
| 1870 Shield Nickel | 1870 | Up to $5 million |
| 1937-D Three-Legged | 1937 | Up to $2.5 million |
| 1942/1 Jefferson | 1942 | Up to $10 million |
| 1885 Liberty Head | 1885 | Up to $8 million |
Your Chance to Find a Fortune
Finding one of these rare nickels is like hitting the jackpot. They could be hidden in old coin rolls, inherited collections, estate sales, or even in jars of spare change.
Experienced collectors often team up with experts and visit coin shows to track down these treasures. But even if you’re new to coin collecting, it’s worth checking your change—you never know when history and fortune might be sitting in your pocket.
These nickels aren’t just currency—they’re pieces of American history that could make you rich. Start your search today, and you just might uncover a $250 million treasure.
1 thought on “5 Super Rare Nickels That Could Be Worth a Shocking $250 Million”